The Secret Italian
Food & Beverage · Italian Supper Club

The Secret Italian

Newburgh House, McLintock Way, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 6BF

Google Maps Updated: 25 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 90/100
About

The Secret Italian is a unique dining experience in Barnsley that feels like a hidden gem. The set menu and BYOB policy are huge hits with customers. While it's hard to get a booking, the atmosphere and food quality make it well worth the effort. It's a cozy, intimate spot that feels like dining with friends.

Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
18
Newest
20
Highest rating
17
Lowest rating

We analyze 75 public reviews for The Secret Italian using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.

Performance Scores
Food Taste 95/100
Value for Money 90/100
Pro Tip

Book months in advance; this place is a local secret that fills up fast.

BYOB policy
Set menu only
Pros & Cons

✓ What Works Well

  • Unique experience
  • Great value
  • Cozy atmosphere

✗ Areas to Improve

  • Hard to book
  • Set menu not for everyone
  • Limited drink options
Frequently Asked Questions
  • How do I book?
  • Is it BYOB?
  • What is the set menu?
User Feedback

Best dining experience in Barnsley

Tiramisu is to die for

Book months in advance

Quick Info